Loading...
Episodes (200)
Secrets of Strixhaven: Jank or Gem?
Are these new Secrets of Strixhaven cards jank or gems? That's what the crew's deciding today!
Apr 13, 20261h 5m
Is the New Ancestral Recall Bait?
The crew talks Secrets of Strixhaven!
Apr 6, 20261h 6m
Are Strixhaven Charms the Next $10 Uncommons?
The crew talks early Secrets of Strixhaven spoilers and answer #MTGFishmail!
Mar 30, 202659 min
"...Will Kill Magic" Tier List
The crew ranks things that were going to kill Magic based on their impact in 2026!
Mar 23, 20261h 17m
You Are Using 17Lands Wrong. Here's How.
The crew's been playing a lot of limited lately and has some thoughts on 17Lands.
Mar 16, 20261h 4m
Control Finisher Tier List
The crew ranks the most iconic control finishers in the game's history!
Mar 9, 20261h 15m
Cowa-bummer: Players Skip TMNT Prerelease
The crew talks TMNT prerelease and dig into some ideas for fixing the legend rule in 2026!
Mar 2, 20261h 2m
TMNT Shills Exposed
The crew talks a wild week of decklist drama and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
Feb 23, 20261h 8m
Is Thoughtseize Even Good in 2026?
The crew talks Hasbro's 2025 financial results and debates what iconic old cards might be safe for 2026 Standard!
Feb 16, 20261h 1m
Are $1,000 Standard Decks Sustainable?
The crew talks today's ban list update, the price of Standard and more!
Feb 9, 20261h 3m
Pro Tour Lorywn Eclipsed Was Shockingly Spectacular
Tomer joins the crew to talk Pro Tour Lorywn Eclipsed and some super early Secrets of Strixhaven spoilers!
Feb 2, 20261h 3m
Would Magic Be Successful If It Launched Today?
The crew talks Hasbro CEO Chris Cocks being sued and delves into a classic Richard hot take about mana screw, new players and more!
Jan 27, 20261h 3m
TMNT Eclipses Lorwyn
This weekend was Lorwyn Eclipsed prerelease, but things didn't exactly go as planned...
Jan 19, 20261h 2m
We Talk Lorwyn Eclipsed With a Pro (Featuring Patrick Chapin)
We talk Lorwyn Eclipsed spoilers with hall of famer Patrick Chapin!
Jan 13, 202659 min
Hatebear Tier List
The crew ranks Magic's most iconic hatebears!
Jan 5, 20261h 10m
2025 Year in Review
The crew takes a look back at all their best (and worst) takes from 2025!
Dec 29, 20251h 35m
80 Percent of Magic Players Don't Play a Real Format
The crew talks Timeless, Standard, a Maro blog post and more!
Dec 22, 202559 min
Is a 1/1 Good If It's Free?
The crew delves into a ton of super early Marvel Super Hero spoilers.
Dec 15, 20251h 13m
Take Backsies in the Top 8 of Worlds
The crew talks Worlds, take backsies in competitive play and answers #MTGFishmail!
Dec 8, 20251h 1m
Canceling a Secret Lair: Good or Bad?
The crew talks Secret Lair cancelations, Worlds, Avatar Limited and more!
Dec 2, 20251h 1m
It's Badgermole Cub's World, We're Just Earthbending In It
The crew talks about a bunch of Modern RCs, Avatar's impact on Standard and more!
Nov 24, 20251h 4m
Avatar Standard First Impressions
Richard and Set discuss their first impressions of Avatar Standard and more!
Nov 17, 20251h 2m
Standard Bannings Reaction
The crew talks about today's ban list update and the best cards from Avatar!
Nov 10, 20251h 11m
We Found the Next Oko in Avatar
The crew talks about the possibility of Magic being in a bubble and a ton of Avatar spoilers!
Nov 3, 20251h 7m
Magic is Going Up, Up, Up
The crew talks the state of Standard, makes some ban list predictions, discusses Hasbro CEO Chris Cocks' comments and more!
Oct 27, 20251h 2m
Sorry for Ruining Spider-Man
Please no Pinkertons.
Oct 20, 202554 min
Is Super Shredder the New Tarmogoyf?
Richard and Seth talk TMNT, Smallpox at Eternal Weekend, the size of Standard and more!
Oct 13, 20251h 1m
Pigs and Slop
Pigs, slop and everything else about this week in Magic.
Oct 6, 20251h 3m
The Universes Beyond War Has Been Lost
Only Jim Halpert can save us now...
Sep 29, 20251h 3m
Are Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Coming to Magic?
The crew talks Spider-man release, a Nickelodeon crossover teaser, this weekend's Modern Pro Tour and more!
Sep 22, 20251h 1m
Did Wizards Accidentally Create Their New Mascot in Fleem?
The crew talks about Vivi potentially being banned in November, Fleem love and more!
Sep 15, 20251h 2m
Is Spider-man a UB Hat Set?
The crew delves deep into Spider-man, and answers #MTGFishmail (also about Spider-man, somehow).
Sep 8, 20251h 3m
No One Is Playing Paper Standard. Is It A Problem?
The crew talks Spotlight Series Planetary Rotation in Orlando, the lack of Standard attendance and Spider-man spoilers!
Sep 1, 20251h 5m
Standard Horizons
The crew talks about how to balance Standard without bannings, answers #MTGFishmail and more!
Aug 25, 202559 min
Can The Avatar Save Standard?
The crew talks Avatar spoilers, the cost of collector boxes and more!
Aug 18, 20251h 0m
Will There Be An Emergency Banning?
The crew talks Izzet Cauldron in Standard, the possibility of Romantasy and K-Pop coming to Magic and answer #MTGFishmail!
Aug 11, 20251h 6m
How to Have a Healthy Relationship with Magic
With Richard away Crim and Seth discuss how to handle Magic's increasing release schedule and dig into post rotation Edge of Eternities Standard!
Aug 4, 20251h 4m
Can Spider-Man Outsell Final Fantasy?
The crew talks Edge of Eternities prerelease, Hasbro's Q2 earnings and super early Spider-man spoilers!
Jul 28, 20251h 0m
We Predict the Future of Standard
The crew discusses wedding Magic, the most impactful cards from Edge of Eternity, Standard rotation and more!
Jul 21, 20251h 4m
Is Station Better Than It Looks?
The crew talks about Edge of Eternities and a ton of new spoilers!
Jul 14, 20251h 2m
Do Collector Booster Prices Matter?
The crew talks post-ban Standard, the cost of Magic, the lack of places for Richard to get sweaty and more!
Jul 7, 20251h 2m
Early Rotation for Standard
The crew breaks down today's massive ban list update and answers #MTGFishmail!
Jun 30, 20251h 5m
MagicCon Vegas 2025
The inside scoop from #MCVegas alongside Edge of Eternities previews.
Jun 23, 202557 min
Final Fantasy Breaks Arena
The crew discusses the first week of Final Fantasy Standard, Richard's limited grind and answers #MTGFishmail!
Jun 16, 20251h 4m
Final Fantasy First Impressions
The crew talks prerelease, early access and more!
Jun 9, 20251h 5m
Is Final Fantasy Overpriced?
Yes.
Jun 2, 20251h 2m
Monstrous Rage is Up to 69%. Nice.
The crew talks the return of Mono-Red to Standard and a ton of Final Fantasy spoilers!
May 26, 20251h 3m
Are Magic Players Lazy?
The crew talks Standard, Izzet Prowess, Regional Championship results and a ton of Final Fantasy!
May 19, 20251h 3m
Vivi and Sephiroth are Insane | Final Fantasy Spoilers
The crew breaks down a ton of new Final Fantasy spoilers!
May 12, 20251h 9m
Stock Up is a $13 Uncommon
The crew talks Standard, the absurdity of current uncommons, Richard's experience trying Alchemy and answers #MTGFishmail!
May 5, 20251h 3m
Would You Buy $100 Foils?
The crew talks about Wizards increasing revenue (and prices), Cori-Steel Cutter in Standard and more before answering #MTGFishmail!
Apr 28, 20251h 9m
Arachnid-Humanoid Comes to MTG Arena
The crew discusses the news that Marvel sets will be replaced by in-universes sets on Arena and break down their favorite fringe formats!
Apr 21, 20251h 3m
Cori-Steel Cutter's the Breakout Card of Tarkir: Dragonstorm
Seth and Richard talk about Tarkir: Dragonstorm, Standard rotation, limited and more before answering #MTGFishmail!
Apr 14, 202559 min
Ban List Philosophy and Dragonstorm Standard with CGB
With Richard and Crim away CovertGoBlue joins Seth to talk Takir: Dragonstorm Standard, Wizards ban list philosophy and more!
Apr 8, 20251h 15m
Bannings and Top Dragonstorm Cards
Seth and Crim break down today's ban list update and share their top 10 Tarkir: Dragonstorm cards!
Mar 31, 20251h 2m
Tarkir: Dragonstorm Spoilers
The crew gives their impressions of Tarkir: Dragonstorm and breaks down a ton of spoilers!
Mar 24, 20251h 7m
Secret Lair: How Niche Is Too Niche?
The crew talks some random spoilers, niche Secret Lair drops and answers a bunch of #MTGFishmail.
Mar 17, 20251h 4m
Krabby Patties Come to Magic
The crew talks Breach dominating Modern and future bans, Kibler's video on Standard and a bunch of spoilers, including Sponge Bob Secret Lairs!
Mar 10, 20251h 4m
Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man Spoilers
The crew talks Spider-man and discuss the impact that the increasing price of Universes Beyond sets will have on Standard.
Mar 3, 20251h 1m
New Mox and Siege Rhino Incoming
The crew talks Pro Tour Aetherdrift, Final Fantasy and Tarkir: Dragonstorm spoilers and answers #MTGFishmail!
Feb 24, 20251h 6m
Would You FNM at Gamestop?
The crew talks about Pro Tour Aetherdrift, discusses some new Final Fantasy Commander spoilers, Game Stop running FNMs and more!
Feb 17, 20251h 5m
First Impression of Aetherdrift Standard
The crew talks Aetherdrift early access, the rise of Underworld Breach in Modern and more!
Feb 10, 20251h 2m
The 18 Aetherdrift Cards that Actually Matter
The crew breaks down the 18 cards from Aetherdrift that they think will impact 60 card constructed Magic!
Feb 3, 20251h 0m
Aetherdrift Spoilers
The crew discusses their first impression of Aetherdrift, break down the new mechanics from the set and a bunch of spoiler cards!
Jan 27, 20251h 4m
Fistfighting for Trading Cards
The crew talks football rules lawyering, people brawling for Pokemon cards, how to beat discard and self-bounce in Standard and more before answering #MTGFishmail!
Jan 20, 20251h 4m
Would You Take a Mana You Didn't Deserve?
The crew breaks down Innistrad Remastered, a random Aetherdrift spoiler, discusses some tournament drama and answers #MTGFishmail!
Jan 13, 20251h 1m
The Biggest Standard Tournament in Years
The crew discusses Showcase Series Atlanta, the state of Standard, some speculation about the last set of 2025, an absurd collection for sale on Ebay and more!
Jan 6, 20251h 3m
2024 Year in Review
The crew looks back on the biggest moments in Magic from 2024.
Dec 30, 20241h 1m
Opal, GSZ, Looting, Twin Unbanned
The Modern shakeup no one expected.
Dec 16, 20241h 1m
League of Legends Wants to Be Magic: the Gathering
The crew talks about a new Riot TCG and discusses next Monday's ban list update and what (if anything) can be done to save Modern!
Dec 9, 20241h 5m
The Most Successful Color Combinations in Magic
The crew discusses some interesting research on what color combos have been the best across Magic's history, Loot, changes to play booster boxes and more!
Dec 2, 20241h 0m
Legacy is Yugioh Now?
The crew talks Eternal Weekend, slabbing in Magic and why black midrange always seems to be at the top of Standard before answering #MTGFishmail.
Nov 25, 20241h 3m
Koma is Good in Modern?
The crew discusses the first week of Foundations, free cards on MTG Arena and more!
Nov 18, 20241h 1m
Marvel Sells Out in Seconds
The crew breaks down their experience trying to buy the Marvel Secret Lair, talks about the future of art in Magic, Foundations prerelease and answers #MTGFishmail.
Nov 11, 20241h 3m
Is Foundations Too Strong?
The crew breaks down Foundations and answers #MTGFishmail.
Nov 4, 20241h 2m
Universes Beyond in Standard
Universes Beyond comes to Standard along with a new release cadence and a SpongeBob Secret Lair!
Oct 28, 20241h 1m
Marvel Secret Lairs a Snap Buy?
The crew talks about the new Marvel Secret Lair drops, the wisdom of signing contracts with Wizards and more before answering #MTGFishmail!
Oct 21, 20241h 5m
Can TCG's Exist Without Gambling?
The crew talks boosters, energy in Modern, Pioneer being sweet and more before answering #MTGFishmail.
Oct 14, 20241h 6m
Tree of Perdition Wins 2,000 Player Tournament
The crew talks about this weekend's Regional Championship, the states of Pioneer, Modern and Standard and even answers #MTGFishmail!
Oct 7, 20241h 2m
Wizards Takes Over The Commander RC
The crew breaks down the latest round of Commander drama, Duskmourn Standard and The One Ring hitting 50% metagame percentage in Modern!
Sep 30, 202459 min
Marvel x Magic: the Gathering Leaked
The crew talks about some upcoming Universes Beyond Marvel cards that showed up on Facebook Market and a surprisingly huge Commander ban list update!
Sep 23, 20241h 5m
The Duskmourn Cards that Actually Matter
The crew breaks down their top Duskmourn cards for Standard, Pioneer, Modern, Legacy and Timeless!
Sep 16, 20241h 7m
Duskmourn Spoilers II
The crew talks a ton of new Duskmourn spoilers!
Sep 10, 20241h 3m
New Titans in Duskmourn
The crew talks Duskmourn spoilers!
Sep 3, 20241h 11m
Huge Ban List Update with Special Guest CGB
With Richard away CGB steps in to help crew break down today's huge ban list update, the Showcase series and more!
Aug 26, 20241h 0m
We Predict the Ban List and Foundations
With Richard away Seth and Crim make predictions for next week's ban list update, discuss what they hope to come to Standard in foundations and more!
Aug 19, 202456 min
What Make a Good Magic Format?
The crew talks Alchemy coming to paper, an update on the $48,000 judge call from last week and discusses what makes for a good Magic: the Gathering format!
Aug 12, 20241h 4m
The $48,000 Judge Call
The crew talks Mystery Boosters 2, some tournament Magic drama, their experiences in new Standard and more!
Aug 5, 20241h 1m
Bloomburrow First Impressions
The crew discusses their first impressions of Bloomburrow, Wizards decision to not ban anything in Modern (yet), Secret Lairs, and even Call of Duty and the value skill based matchmaking in Magic!
Jul 29, 20241h 7m
Bloomburrow: Top Constructed Cards
The crew breaks down their top Bloomburrow cards for Standard, Pioneer and Modern!
Jul 22, 20241h 1m
Will Sunspine Lynx Be Banned?
The crew talks Bloomburrow and a ton of new spoilers!
Jul 15, 20241h 6m
Should The One Ring Be Restricted?
The crew talks about the state of Modern, the lack of a Grief banning in Legacy, Bloomburrow and Duskmourn spoilers and more!
Jul 8, 202456 min
Nadu, Nadu, Nadu, Nadu, Nadu
The crew talks Pro Tour Modern Horizons 3, the dominance of Nadu and a bunch of spoilers!
Jul 1, 20241h 4m
Control is Back in Modern
The crew talks a lackluster B&R update, Assassin's Creed and the state of Modern with a Pro Tour on the horizon next weekend!
Jun 24, 20241h 0m
MH3 Turns Modern Upside Down
The crew discusses the huge impact Modern Horizons 3 is having on Modern (also Timeless and even a little Legacy)!
Jun 17, 20241h 4m
I Played Early Access and We Already Need Bannings
The crew talks their first impressions of Modern Horizons 3, Richard becoming a sweaty One Piece grinder and more!
Jun 10, 20241h 6m
The Top 20 Modern Cards from Modern Horizons 3
The crew counts down their top 20 Modern cards from Modern Horizons 3!
Jun 3, 20241h 3m
New Necropotence Sucks, Quote It
The crew talks Modern Horizons 3 spoilers!
May 27, 20241h 6m
Are MagicCons Worth It?
The crew discusses whether a new Modern Horizons 3 artifact can shake up the Modern meta, ponder if MagicCons are worth the price, break down Crim's experience with Heist on MTG Arena and answer #MTGFishmail.
May 20, 20241h 3m
When Rule Zero Fails at a Standard Tournament
The crew talks today's ban list update, some deal breaking drama at a regional championship, new Secret Lairs and more!
May 13, 20241h 3m
New Tarmogoyf, and It's So Bad
The crew talks a ton of Modern Horizons 3 spoilers, a $3 million Black Lotus and a Comic Sans Secret Lair drop.
May 6, 20241h 2m
Pro Tour Thunder Junction
The crew talks Pro Tour Outlaws of Thunder Junction, Hasbro's Q1 earnings and the future of Magic Arena!
Apr 29, 20241h 3m
Cowboy Bebop Promos
The crew talks Wizards president leaving, some new Cowboy Bebop themed promos, and upcoming Pro Tour and the impact of Outlaws of Thunder Junction on constructed!
Apr 22, 20241h 1m
Is Loot the Next Happy Meal Toy?
The crew gives their first impressions on Outlaws of Thunder Junction, discusses some massive updates on MTGO and Arena and answers #MTGFishmail!
Apr 15, 20241h 4m
Top Constructed Cards from Outlaws of Thunder Junction
The crew counts down their top 10 constructed cards from Outlaws of Thunder Junction!
Apr 8, 20241h 1m
Is Outlaws a Power Creep Set?
The crew delves into the new mechanics, cards and power level of Outlaws of Thunder Junction!
Apr 1, 20241h 3m
Do You Know Magic Slang?
The crew discusses Maro's Outlaws of Thunder Junction teaser, some organized play news and Seth quizzes Richard and Crim on Magic slang terms!
Mar 25, 20241h 2m
Are These MTG Arena Conspiracy Theories Real?
Seth and Crim discuss post-ban Modern, Crim's recent Standard tournament and whether or not a massive list of MTG Arena conspiracy theories are real!
Mar 18, 20241h 1m
This Podcast Should've Been An Article
With Crim away Seth and Richard discuss today's ban list update, the state of written content in Magic, meme card designs and more before answering #MTGFishmail!
Mar 11, 202459 min
Are Certain Card Variants Ban Worthy?
With Richard away Seth and Crim discuss the wisdom of bannings foils and card variants, getting kicked out of a tournament for having too strong of a deck and what Modern Horizons 3 could bring to Timeless on Arena before answering #MTGFishmail!
Mar 4, 20241h 0m
Wizards Just Previewed the Next Year of Magic!
With Crim still making his way back from MagicCon Chicago, Richard and Seth talk Pro Tour Murders at Karlov Manor, Wizards cutting some languages from the game and a ton of spoilers!
Feb 26, 20241h 6m
Is it Okay to Lie in a Tournament?
The crew discusses more Universes Beyond being on the way, lying in tournaments, a Sheldon themed Secret Lair drop and Fallout spoilers!
Feb 19, 20241h 3m
Surveil Lands Broken
The crew discusses the impact of Murders at Karlov Manor on Standard, Pioneer, Modern and answer #MTGFishmail!
Feb 12, 20241h 3m
The Long Awaited Sorcery Speed Counterspell
The crew talks Murders at Karlov Manor, new Secret Lairs, Wizards shockingly lacking quality control and answers #MTGFishmail!
Feb 5, 20241h 3m
The Most Exciting Cards from Murders at Karlov Manor
The crew breaks down Murders of Karlov Manor for 60 card constructed formats by discussing the ten best cards in the set!
Jan 29, 20241h 5m
Omega Morph and Omega Manifest
The crew discusses a ton of new Murders at Karlov Manor spoilers!
Jan 22, 20241h 2m
Who is the Sweatiest Goldfish?
The crew spends the entire cast answering your #MTGFishmail questions!
Jan 15, 20241h 3m
The Drama Cast
The crew discusses a huge week of MTG drama and answers #fishmail!
Jan 8, 20241h 2m
2023: Year in Review
The crew looks back on some of their best (and worst) predictions of 2023 and then looks ahead to 2024!
Jan 1, 20241h 10m
I Haven't Had This Much Fun Playing Arena in Years
The crew discusses Timeless on MTG Arena, the issues with Ravnica Remastered, massive layoffs at Hasbro and Wizards and Richard's quest to break Modern with Standard cards before answering #MTGFishmail.
Dec 18, 20231h 4m
Is Lightning Helix Still S Tier?
Richard and Crim break down Murders at Karlov Manor spoilers!
Dec 11, 20231h 6m
Wizards Takes Their Fury Out On Modern
The crew breaks down today's huge ban list update and answers #MTGFishmail!
Dec 4, 20231h 1m
We Tell Wizards How to Fix Modern
Modern is in a weird place and the Goldfish crew has some ideas about how to fix it.
Nov 27, 20231h 3m
These Ixalan Cards Top 8ed This Weekend
The crew talks about some upcoming promos, the future of Standard, Lost Cavern of Ixalan's impact on various constructed formats and answers #MTGFishmail!
Nov 20, 20231h 1m
Universes Beyond Tier List
With the crew waiting for Lost Caverns of Ixalan to release they tier list all of the Universes Beyond sets released so far!
Nov 13, 20231h 5m
The Most Exciting Cards from Lost Caverns of Ixalan
Seth and Richard discuss their top Lost Caverns of Ixalan cards for various 60 card constructed formats!
Nov 6, 20231h 2m
We Discover Lost Caverns of Ixalan
The crew talks Lost Caverns of Ixalan spoilers!
Oct 30, 20231h 2m
Marvel is Coming to Magic
The crew discusses a ton of Universes Beyond news and how to fix Modern
Oct 23, 20231h 0m
Drafting Just Got More Expensive
Seth and Richard discuss play boosters, a "no changes" ban list update and answer #MTGFishmail
Oct 16, 20231h 1m
Is Magic Still the #1 TCG?
The crew talks Doctor Who, Magic's current place in the TCG universe, Arena Championship IV and more before answering #MTGFishmail!
Oct 9, 20231h 4m
Is Ghalta Win More?
The crew discussing the upcoming Arena Championship IV and a ton of spoilers!
Oct 2, 20231h 2m
MagicCon Vegas 2023
The whole MTGGoldfish crew gets together to talk about their experience at MagicCon Vegas live from the Westgate Hotel in Las Vegas!
Sep 25, 20231h 1m
We Take the Wilds of Eldraine Survey
The crew talks a new My Little Pony Secret Lair, the state of MTG Arena and lets Wizards know what they think about Wilds of Eldraine by taking the new survey!
Sep 18, 20231h 6m
Cascade and Naya and Golgari and Faeries
The crew talks about the impact of Wilds of Eldraine on various constructed formats and answers #MTGFishmail!
Sep 11, 20231h 3m
The End (of Sheoldred)?
The crew gives their first impressions of Wilds of Eldraine Standard and talks Dr. Who spoilers!
Sep 4, 20231h 3m
Can Eldraine Beat Sheoldred?
The crew gives their impression of the full Wilds of Eldraine set, discusses the future of Standard, checks out some new Secret Lair drops and answers #MTGFishmail!
Aug 28, 20231h 3m
The Most Broken Eldraine Card = Spreading Seas?
With Richard sick and Crim without internet because of a storm Tomer joins Seth to discuss Wilds of Eldraine and answer #MTGFishmail!
Aug 21, 202359 min
Did Commander Masters Flop?
The crew discusses the issues with Commander Masters, some new promos, anime Smothering Tithe and answers #MTGFishmail.
Aug 14, 20231h 2m
Yee Haw, We're Cowboys Now
The crew breaks down today's surprising ban list update, a huge list of upcoming sets and more!
Aug 7, 202359 min
Is Every Deck in Modern a Scam?
Seth and Richard discuss Pro Tour Lord of the Rings, power creep in Magic and Wilds of Eldraine spoilers!
Jul 31, 20231h 1m
We Rate Doctor Who Cards, but Know Nothing About Doctor Who
With Crim traveling to MagicCon Barcelona, Richard and Seth try to figure out Doctor Who, discuss the current state of Modern heading into the upcoming Pro Tour, Commander Masters precon prices and more!
Jul 24, 20231h 0m
Is It Worth Buying a Box of Commander Masters?
The crew discusses Commander Masters, when Pioneer will finally make it to Arena, how they would rebalance some cards for Historic and more before answering #MTGFishmail.
Jul 17, 20231h 1m
What's the Best Titan in 2023?
The crew discuss the new Historic and Explorer Anthologies coming to MTG Arena, consider whether Jace, the Mind Sculptor could ever come back to Standard and answer #MTGFishmail.
Jul 10, 20231h 0m
Our Picks for Worst Mechanics
With Crim in a boondoggle Richard and Seth discuss The One Ring being opened, it's impact on Modern, new Secret Lair drops and weigh in on the worst mechanics ever before answering #MTGFishmail.
Jul 3, 20231h 6m
The One Ring to Rule Modern
The crew gives their first impression of Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth, discusses some new Modern brews and answers #MTGFishmail.
Jun 26, 20231h 1m
Is Universes Beyond the New Reserved List?
With Crim traveling Richard and Seth talk Lord of the Rings, Standard, Alchemy on Arena, the Ambassador program and more before answering #MTGFishmail.
Jun 19, 202359 min
Smeagol Plus Crabs Equals the Answer to Modern
The crew discusses Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-Earth, the current state of Pioneer and answers #MTGFishmail.
Jun 12, 20231h 3m
Will Anything From Lord of the Rings See Play in Modern?
The crew shares their takes on post-banning Standard and discusses which Lord of the Rings cards could show up in Modern!
Jun 5, 20231h 5m
Fable Free Standard!
With Richard away Crim and Seth discuss Standard bannings, Arena coming to Steam, the impending Lord of the Rings preview season and answer #MTGFishmail.
May 29, 20231h 0m
Our Banning Predictions
The crew talks about Wizards new philosophy for bannings, shares what they would ban in Standard and more!
May 22, 20231h 1m
Aftermath Flopped, Where Does Standard Go from Here?
The crew discusses Aftermath, the future of Standard and answers #MTGFishmail.
May 15, 20231h 1m
Wizards "Fixes" Standard
With Crim away Seth and Richard discuss Pro Tour March of the Machine, some huge changes to Standard, a bunch of spoiler news and answer #MTGFishmail.
May 8, 20231h 1m
Why are These Cards Banned in Modern? (Part 2)
The crew finishes their breakdown of the Modern banned list!
May 1, 20231h 12m
March of the Machine First Impressions
Richard and Seth talk about their first impression of March of the Machine, discuss a wild story about how Aftermath leaked and answer #MTGFishmail!
Apr 24, 20231h 2m
Cards that Used to Be Good in Modern
With Crim away Richard and Seth discuss serialized cards and delve deep into cards that used to be awesome in Modern, but don't show up anymore before answering #MTGFishmail.
Apr 17, 20231h 4m
March of the Machine Praetor Ranking
Seth and Richard discuss Blade of Shared Souls in Standard, rank the Praetors from March of the Machine and answer #MTGFishmail.
Apr 10, 20231h 4m
Battle(cruiser) Magic is Finally Here
The crew breaks down battles and talks a ton of new March of the Machines spoilers!
Apr 3, 20231h 10m
Is Elspeth Better Than Wrenn, Actually?
The crew discusses March of the Machines early spoilers, an upcoming D&D Secret Lair drop and more before answering #MTGFishmail!
Mar 27, 20231h 5m
Magic Just Printed the Rarest Card Ever
The crew talks Arena Championship II, Lord of the Rings and the impact of the 1 of 1 The One Ring.
Mar 20, 20231h 13m
Why are These Cards Banned in Modern?
The crew dives deep into the Modern banned list.
Mar 13, 20231h 8m
What Does Shadows Over Innistrad Add to Arena?
The crew is joined by special guest Joe Dyer to discuss today's Legacy bannings, breaks down the impact of Shadows over Innistrad to Magic Arena and more before answering #MTGFishmail!
Mar 6, 20231h 5m
Would You Dig Through Garbage for Magic Cards?
The crew discusses Commander Masters, dumpster diving for Magic and more!
Feb 27, 20231h 0m
Paper Magic is Back! (jk, more spoilers)
Seth and Richard discuss Pro Tour Phyrexia and a ton of early spoilers from March of the Machines!
Feb 20, 20231h 9m
Phyrexia: All Is Standard
The crew discusses Phyrexia: All Will Be One Standard and answers #MTGFishmail!
Feb 13, 20231h 5m
Phyrexia First Impressions
Seth and Richard discuss the Phyrexia: All Will Be One early access event, #DongGate, Dockside Extortionist and answer #MTGFishmail.
Feb 6, 202359 min
Is Phyrexia the Best Set Since Eldraine?
The crew finishes up Phyrexia: All Will Be One spoiler season by discussing the full set, talks about Hasbro's layoffs and what they mean for Magic and answers #MTGFishmail!
Jan 30, 20231h 3m
What's the Matter with Jace?
The crew talks Phyrexia: All Will Be One spoilers and speculates on what the new Battle card type might be!
Jan 23, 20231h 7m
What Phyrexia Planeswalker is Best?
The crew talks Phyrexia: All Will Be One spoilers, an update on the D&D open gaming license and answers #MTGFishmail!
Jan 16, 2023
Phyrexia: All Will Be Leaked
The crew discusses why a ton of Phyrexia cards leaked this weekend, discuss their feelings on various constructed formats heading into 2023 and answer #MTGFishmail.
Jan 9, 20231h 2m
2022 Previews in Review
The crew looks back on their 2022 predictions to see what they got right and what they got horribly wrong.
Jan 2, 20231h 20m
Holiday Fishmail Bag
The crew wraps up 2022 by spending the entire cast answering your #MTGFishmail questions!
Dec 26, 20221h 1m
Is Phyrexian Obliterator Good in 2023?
The crew talks Phyrexia: All Will Be One spoilers, the Storm Scale and answers #MTGFishmail!
Dec 19, 20221h 2m
Initiative Breaks Legacy and Vintage
The crew talks Eternal Weekend, Initiative in eternal formats, Dominaria Remastered, Hasbro's Fireside Chat and more!
Dec 12, 20221h 3m
MTG Hot Takes
The crew shares their Magic: the Gathering hot takes.
Dec 5, 20221h 0m
30th Anniversary Edition "Sold Out"
The crew talks Jumpstart 2022, more controversary regarding 30th Anniversary Edition and answers #MTGFishmail
Nov 28, 20221h 4m
Disqualified for Playing Secret Lairs?
The crew discusses Pioneer, this weekend's Regional Championships, a player getting DQed for playing Secret Lair foils, Wizards shutting down a custom card site and answers #MTGFishmail.
Nov 21, 20221h 7m
Hasbro's Stock is Not for You
The crew discusses Golden Packs on Arena, Transformers coming to MTGO, answers Aaron Forsythe's question about why paper Standard is dying and breaks down Bank of America's take on Hasbro, Wizards and Magic before answering #MTGFishmail.
Nov 14, 20221h 1m
Timmy and The Brothers' War
The crew breaks down a ton of new The Brothers' War spoilers!
Nov 7, 20221h 11m
Everything Magic 30
Live from Vegas, the crew recounts their Magic 30 experience, joined by Brewer's Kitchen and BudgetCommander.
Oct 31, 202258 min
75% of Players Don't Know Planeswalkers?
The crew talks early Jumpstart 2022 spoilers, the difference between casuals and enfranchised players and answers #MTGFishmail.
Oct 24, 20221h 0m
Things That Could Kill Magic in 2022
The crew discusses post-Meatball Standard, a bunch of new Secret Lair drops and revisit an old Mark Rosewater article about things that were going to kill Magic by adding some 2022 updates!
Oct 17, 20221h 5m
Insert Angry Magic 30 A Title Here
The crew discusses a huge ban list update, 30th Anniversary Edition and more Universes Beyond crossovers.
Oct 10, 20221h 3m
Converters: More than Meets the Eye
The crew discusses a ton of announcements including a first look at The Brothers War, Transformers coming to Magic, Pioneer Challenger decks and more!
Oct 3, 20221h 7m
How Do You Beat Hat Tribal?
The crew discusses Arena Championship I, Unfinity and answers #MTGFishmail.
Sep 26, 20221h 1m
Are Warhammer 40k Precons the Best Precons Ever?
The crew discusses the full Warhammer 40k Commander decklists, pauper bannings and the upcoming Arena Championship I before answering #MTGFishmail!
Sep 19, 20221h 5m
Is Meathook Too Good?
The crew talks Dominaria United Standard, Warhammer 40k spoilers, Lorcana and answers #MTGFishmail.
Sep 12, 202253 min
Time to Dust Off Those Lilianas
The crew discusses the impact of Dominaria United in Standard, Pioneer and Modern, Disney making a new game to compete with Magic and answers #MTGFishmail.
Sep 5, 20221h 0m
What's the Best Dominaria United Lord?
The crew breaks down Dominaria United, limited being solved to quickly and answers #MTGFishmail.
Aug 29, 20221h 1m
Is Karn Top 5 Worst Planeswalkers Ever?
The crew discusses TCGPlayer being bought by Ebay, Dr. Who coming to Magic and Dominaria United spoilers!
Aug 22, 20221h 6m
Is Lil' Giri the New Pikachu?
The crew talks the cost of Magic 30, it's exclusive Secret Lair Drop, delve into some Dominaria United news and answers #MTGFishmail.
Aug 15, 20221h 1m
What's the Best Card in Modern?
With Crim internet-less Seth and Richard argue about which card should be considered the best card in Modern and answer #MTGFishmail.
Aug 8, 20221h 4m
What Did Wizards Learn in 2022?
The crew goes in-depth on the new Explorer and Historic Anthology releases, discusses Mark Rosewater's State of Design 2022 article and answers #MTGFishmail!
Aug 1, 20221h 0m
Acorns, Legends and Stickers
The crew discusses a ton of spoilers ranging from Dominaria United to Unfinity to Explorer Anthologies!
Jul 25, 20221h 0m
CFB TCG OMG
The crew discusses TCGPlayer buying ChannelFireball, a Magic Online prize cut, Grinning Ignus seemingly dying for nothing and much more, before (of course) answering your #MTGFishmail.
Jul 18, 202259 min
The Technology for Coverage is Here
The crew discusses Alchemy bannings, Fortnite coming to Magic and community-lead coverage showing off a huge Modern $30k in Syracuse before answering #MTGFishmail.
Jul 11, 202257 min
Answering Life's Most Important Questions
The crew spends the entire cast answering life's most important questions, as submitted by all of you!
Jul 4, 20221h 14m
Is Double Masters 2022 Worth $400 a Box?
The crew discusses Double Masters 2022, its relationship to Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate, the return of the greatest Brawl player in the world and answers #MTGFishmail!
Jun 27, 20221h 2m
Where Are The Modern Cards In Double Masters 2022?
The crew discusses Double Masters 2022, an $800,000 Black Lotus, format popularity on Magic Arena and answers #MTGFishmail!
Jun 20, 20221h 1m
Shrinkflation Comes to Magic
The crew talks Pioneer bannings, some Magic booster boxes offering less packs, a new Secret Lair drop and more!
Jun 13, 202259 min
Stories from Commandfest Richmond
The crew talks about their weekend at Commandfest Richmond.
Jun 7, 202258 min